| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 37 | Andrew Alameda | 2021 | Farmingdale Senior | Farmingdale | NY | USA | RHP |
| Mid-State Mavericks | 32 | Evan Alander | 2021 | Hershey | Hershey | PA | USA | RHP |
| RCBC Royals | 45 | Ayden Allen | 2021 | St. Peter's Boys | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| RCBC Nationals | 14 | Mike Alongi | 2021 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | 3B |
| Dodgers Elite | 5 | Santo Anzalone | 2021 | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | Middle Village | NY | USA | 1B |
| Keystone War Eagles | 10 | Carson Applegate | 2022 | The Hun | Columbus | NJ | USA | SS |
| RCBC Royals | 32 | Nikolas Ballestero | 2021 | New Dorp | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| Keystone War Eagles | 37 | Alec Baltz | 2021 | Shawnee | Medford | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Keystone War Eagles | 14 | Nick Barone | 2022 | Loyalsock Twp | Montoursville | PA | USA | 1B |
| Dodgers Elite | 19 | Noel Batista | 2022 | Suffield Academy | Bellmore | NY | USA | 2B |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 5 | Jake Baumann | 2022 | Delran | Delran | NJ | USA | 3B |
| HV Bulldogs | 7 | Dan Beal | 2021 | John Jay Senior | Hopewell Junction | NY | USA | RHP |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 24 | Jack Belbot | 2021 | Loyola-Blakefield | Baltimore | MD | USA | OF |
| NJ Axemen | 4 | Nick Bergamotto | 2022 | James Caldwell | Caldwell | NJ | USA | SS |
| NY Prospects | 13 | Michael Bianco | 2021 | Xaverian | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| PA Playmakers | 28 | Connor Booth | 2022 | Oxford Area | Oxford | PA | USA | C |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 15 | Scott Borgmann | 2021 | Calvert Hall College | Parkton | MD | USA | 3B |
| Pascack Valley | 6 | Jason Boss | 2021 | Pascack Valley | Hillsdale | NJ | USA | OF |
| North Atlantic Select | 24 | Alex Boswell | 2021 | Mamaroneck | Larchmont | NY | USA | RHP |
| Legends Prospects | 2 | JR Bozek | 2022 | Phillips Exeter Academy | Danville | NH | USA | MIF |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 10 | Jack Brenner | 2022 | Ridge | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | OF |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 23 | Mason Burke | 2021 | Loyola-Blakefield | Baltimore | MD | USA | C |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 88 | Coltrane Calloway | 2021 | Bay Shore Senior | Bay Shore | NY | USA | OF |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 39 | Chris Campanella | 2021 | Baylor | Marshall | NC | USA | RHP |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 6 | Shane Cangemi | 2021 | Archbishop Ryan | Philadelphia | PA | USA | 3B |
| NJ Axemen | 25 | Dominick Carlucci | 2021 | Seton Hall Preparatory | Clark | NJ | USA | C |
| Legends Prospects | 4 | James Carmilia | 2022 | Danvers | Danvers | MA | USA | OF |
| Dodgers Elite | 20 | Leonardo Carpio | 2021 | High School for Construction | South Richmond Hill | NY | USA | LHP |
| Diamond Jacks Gold | 7 | Frank Castovinci | 2021 | Easton Area | Easton | PA | USA | OF |
| North Atlantic Select | 27 | Tyler Caton | 2022 | Palm Beach Central | Wellington | FL | USA | OF |
| LumberKings | 23 | Gabriel Cavazzoni | 2023 | Wall | Wall | NJ | USA | SS |
| MVP Blue Jackets | 2 | Derek Cease | 2021 | Greater Nanticoke Area | Plymouth | PA | USA | SS |
| North Atlantic Select | 8 | Bobby Chicoine | 2022 | Byram Hills | Armonk | NY | USA | RHP |
| NY Storm Albany | 5 | Daniel Cohen | 2022 | South Glens Falls Senior | Gansevoort | NY | USA | RHP |
| Dodgers Elite | 1 | Giovanni Colasante | 2022 | Poly Prep Country Day | Staten Island | NY | USA | SS |
| LumberKings Blue | 32 | Ryan Cole | 2022 | Neptune | Neptune City | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 14 | Tory Cooks | 2021 | Millennium Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | USA | OF |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 7 | Daniel Corona | 2021 | Baylor | Brooklyn | NY | USA | SS |
| Mid-State Mavericks | 51 | Jacob Cortes | 2021 | Red Land (Lewisberry, PA) | Etters | PA | USA | C |
| Keystone War Eagles | 5 | Ryan Costello | 2021 | Manchester Twp | Toms River | NJ | USA | OF |
| Team Beast Red | 25 | Tyler Cox | 2021 | W Tresper Clarke | Westbury | NY | USA | OF |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 21 | Dominic Crema | 2022 | Smithtown West | Smithtown | NY | USA | 2B |
| LumberKings Blue | 88 | Bobby Cucciniello | 2022 | Wall | Wall | NJ | USA | OF |
| PA Playmakers | 2 | Logan Culp | 2021 | West Chester Henderson | West Chester | PA | USA | 3B |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 27 | Maddix Dalena | 2022 | Montoursville Area | Cogan Station | PA | USA | 1B |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 32 | Andrew D'Alessio | 2021 | Xavier | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| MVP Blue Jackets | 14 | Xander Davis | 2022 | Abington Heights (Clarks Summit, PA) | Clarks Summit | PA | USA | OF |
| NY Storm Albany | 14 | Kyle DeCresce | 2022 | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake Senior | Glenville | NY | USA | 3B |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 7 | Noah Deluca | 2021 | Arundel | Odenton | MD | USA | SS |
| Dodgers Elite | 11 | Alexander Diaz | 2021 | The Gunnery | Brooklyn | NY | USA | SS |
| Bronx Bombers | 24 | Evan Diaz | 2021 | All Hallows | Yonkers | NY | USA | 3B |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 11 | Antonio DiGrigoli | 2022 | Rabun Gap Nacoochee | Brooklyn | NY | USA | C |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 23 | Justin Dilorenzo | 2022 | Connetquot | Ronkonkama | NY | USA | SS |
| Apreda Baseball Club | 18 | Brock Donnelly | 2022 | Hough | Huntersville | NC | USA | C |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 11 | Conner Dreyer | 2022 | Delbarton | Chatham | NJ | USA | MIF |
| Team Beast Red | 27 | Matthew Edwards | 2021 | Commack | East Northport | NY | USA | RHP |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 43 | Connor English | 2022 | Archbishop Ryan | Philadelphia | PA | USA | 1B |
| Legends Prospects | 18 | Roman Ercoli | 2021 | Concord Carlisle | Concord | MA | USA | RHP |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 4 | Nick Farlow | 2021 | Archbishop Ryan | Philadelphia | PA | USA | SS |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 34 | Aeden Finateri | 2021 | IMG Academy | Watertown | CT | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 80 | Evan Fisher | 2021 | Sachem East | Holtsville | NY | USA | 1B |
| NJ Axemen | 34 | Gabriel Francisco | 2022 | Rutherford | Rutherford | NJ | USA | OF |
| Team Beast Red | 4 | Daniel Franzese | 2021 | Deer Park | Deer Park | NY | USA | 2B |
| NJ Axemen | 21 | Ellis Garcia | 2022 | St. Joseph's Regional | Elmwood Park | NJ | USA | SS |
| Hudson County Huskies | 3 | Jaiden Garcia | 2022 | James J Ferris | Jersey City | NJ | USA | 2B |
| NY Prospects | 23 | Joseph Garofalo | 2021 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | LHP |
| Legit Baseball Club | 14 | Aj Giannetti | 2021 | Albertus Magnus (Bardonia, NY) | New City | NY | USA | C |
| RCBC Nationals | 16 | Nick Girellini | 2021 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 12 | Henry Godbout | 2022 | Baylor | Brooklyn | NY | USA | SS |
| Team Beast Red | 14 | Nicholas Goldberg | 2021 | Commack | Commack | NY | USA | RHP |
| Cage Academy | 20 | Christopher Gonzalez | 2022 | Raritan | Hazlet | NJ | USA | SS |
| RCBC Nationals | 8 | David Goodman | 2022 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| LumberKings | 18 | Zachary Gorman | 2021 | Freehold Twp | Freehold | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Diamond Jacks Gold | 19 | Jared Greenzang | 2022 | Hopewell Valley Central | Titusville | NJ | USA | RHP |
| HV Bulldogs | 4 | Gavin Gropusso | 2022 | Kingston (Kingston, NY) | Kingston | NY | USA | OF |
| HV Bulldogs | 10 | Alex Grzechowski | 2021 | Marlboro Central (Marlboro, NY) | Marlboro | NY | USA | SS |
| NY Prospects | 12 | Steve Guerra | 2021 | Xaverian (Brooklyn, NY) | Staten Island | NY | USA | C |
| Bronx Bombers | 14 | Adonys Guzman | 2022 | Brunswick | Valley Cottage | NY | USA | C |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 15 | Jake Hall | 2022 | Longwood | Coram | NY | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 4 | Rocco Hall | 2022 | Longwood | Coram | NY | USA | C |
| Brooklyn Bluestorm Elite | 3 | Chris Hayes | 2021 | School 7-Oceanside Senior | Oceanside | NY | USA | RHP |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 2 | Kyle Hellam | 2022 | Mechanicsburg Area | Mechanisburg | PA | USA | OF |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 2 | Keegan Holles | 2022 | Cherry Creek | Centennial | CO | USA | OF |
| NY Storm Astoria | 27 | Byram Hot | 2022 | Undecided | Astoria | NY | USA | RHP |
| Cage Academy | 11 | Benjamin Hutchins | 2022 | Raritan | Hazlet | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Legends Prospects | 10 | Ryan Hutchinson | 2021 | Hamilton-Wenham Reg | Hamilton | MA | USA | 3B |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 20 | Mikey Jensen | 2021 | Loyola-Blakefield | Cockeysville | MD | USA | RHP |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 3 | Ryan Kelly | 2021 | Loyola-Blakefield (Baltimore, MD) | Baltimore | MD | USA | 2B |
| Long Island Tigers | 8 | Richard Kershow | 2022 | Northport | Eatons Neck | NY | USA | C |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 15 | Alexander Kim | 2022 | Seton Hall Preparatory | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | SS |
| Keystone War Eagles | 31 | Nick Kirkessner | 2022 | East Pennsboro Area | Enola | PA | USA | RHP |
| Mid-State Mavericks | 21 | Brandon Koch | 2021 | | New Cumberland | PA | USA | OF |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 16 | Gavin Krietz | 2022 | Ridge | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | OF |
| North Atlantic Select | 10 | Zachary Kringdon | 2021 | Mamaroneck | Larchmont | NY | USA | C |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 32 | Sam Kulp | 2021 | Carlisle Area | Carlisle | PA | USA | RHP |
| Dodgers Elite | 29 | Jonathan Larrea | 2022 | Baylor | Queens | NY | USA | C |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 12 | Thomas Lebrecht | 2021 | Chaminade | Smithtown | NY | USA | OF |
| Legends Prospects | 23 | Colin Lemieux | 2021 | Bishop Hendricken | Warwick | RI | USA | 3B |
| HV Bulldogs | 42 | Michael Lepere | 2021 | Beacon | Beacon | NY | USA | OF |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 21 | Colin Leyner | 2021 | St. Joseph | Edison | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Bronx Bombers | 17 | Michael Lombardi | 2022 | Fox Lane | Pound Ridge | NY | USA | SS |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 27 | Nick Lombardo | 2022 | Upper Dublin | Willow Grove | PA | USA | SS |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 22 | Matt Long | 2021 | Holy Ghost Prep | Philadelphia | PA | USA | RHP |
| Marlboro Gold | 41 | Josh Mack | 2022 | Marlboro | Morganville | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Body Armor Titans | 29 | Joseph Marchese | 2022 | Shoreham-Wading River (Shoreham, NY) | Shoreham | NY | USA | OF |
| Hudson County Huskies | 6 | Nicholas Marcketta | 2021 | Toms River North | Toms River | NJ | USA | SS |
| Legends Prospects | 9 | Peter Martin | 2021 | St. John's Preparatory | Manchester | MA | USA | RHP |
| MVP Blue Jackets | 3 | Nick Matson | 2022 | Greater Nanticoke Area | Nanticoke | PA | USA | OF |
| NY Prospects | 5 | Christopher Mattioli | 2021 | Monsignor Farrell | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 24 | Cameron Mays | 2021 | Ridge | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | C |
| Legends Prospects | 28 | Tom McAndrews | 2022 | Phillips Academy | Haverhill | MA | USA | C |
| Legends Prospects | 14 | Luke McClintock | 2021 | Hamilton-Wenham Reg | Hamilton | MA | USA | RHP |
| PA Playmakers | 14 | Ryan McDonough | 2021 | West Chester Bayard Rustin | West Chester | PA | USA | 1B |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 7 | Cole McGourty | 2021 | North Hunterdon Reg | Asbury | NJ | USA | RHP |
| North Atlantic Select | 9 | Michael Melillo | 2022 | Pequannock Twp | Pompton Plains | NJ | USA | 3B |
| NY Prospects | 21 | Nicholas Messina | 2021 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | 1B |
| RCBC Nationals | 13 | Jaden Mintz | 2021 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | SS |
| Hudson County Huskies | 31 | Quincy Mitchell | 2021 | Bayonne | Bayonne | NJ | USA | OF |
| Apreda Baseball Club | 12 | Dillon Morrow | 2021 | Teaneck (Teaneck, NJ) | Teaneck | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Keystone War Eagles | 19 | Marshall Mott | 2021 | Gettysburg Area | Gettysburg | PA | USA | LHP |
| MVP Blue Jackets | 4 | Tyler Mullen | 2022 | Lakeland | Scott Township | PA | USA | RHP |
| NJ Axemen | 7 | Myles Nova | 2022 | Cuthbertson | Fair Lawn | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Dodgers Elite | 13 | Robert Nunez | 2021 | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | New York | NY | USA | LHP |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 12 | Michael Olivo | 2022 | Ridge | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | OF |
| Legends Prospects | 31 | Payton Palladino | 2022 | St. John's Preparatory | Danvers | MA | USA | 2B |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 16 | Neftali Parache | 2021 | Hotchkiss | Brooklyn | NY | USA | RHP |
| RCBC Nationals | 1 | Ron Patterson | 2021 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Dodgers Elite | 7 | Raymond Pereira | 2022 | Holy Cross | Jamaica | NY | USA | C |
| Baltimore Redbirds | 14 | Noah Perkinson | 2021 | Towson High Law & Public Policy | Towson | MD | USA | RHP |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 7 | Nicholas Petrillo | 2022 | Somerville | Branchburg | NJ | USA | SS |
| North Atlantic Select | 11 | Johnny Pilla | 2022 | Don Bosco Prep | Ridgewood | NJ | USA | SS |
| RCBC Nationals | 23 | Matt Polemeni | 2021 | Moore Catholic | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 6 | Alex Prata | 2021 | North Hunterdon Reg | Lebanon | NJ | USA | 2B |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 1 | Collin Quintano | 2022 | Notre Dame | Easton | PA | USA | SS |
| LumberKings | 19 | Jacob Ramirez | 2022 | St. John Vianney | Matawan | NJ | USA | C |
| HV Bulldogs | 29 | Roberto Reade | 2022 | Newburgh Free Academy (Newburgh, NY) | Newburgh | NY | USA | C |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 2 | Christian Reed | 2022 | Penncrest | Media | PA | USA | C |
| North Atlantic Select | 12 | Noah Rodriguez | 2021 | Don Bosco Prep | Cliffside Park | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Dodgers Elite | 42 | Alexander Rosario | 2022 | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | Astoria | NY | USA | RHP |
| NY Prospects | 10 | Matt Rupp | 2021 | Susan E Wagner | Staten Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| NY Storm Albany | 9 | Alex Russo | 2022 | Niskayuna | Glenville | NY | USA | OF |
| NJ Axemen | 19 | Connor Saslow | 2022 | Ramapo | Wyckoff | NJ | USA | SS |
| Keystone War Eagles | 17 | Logan Sauve | 2022 | Cumberland Valley | Boiling Springs | PA | USA | C |
| LumberKings | 31 | Jayce Schapiro | 2021 | Freehold Twp | Freehold | NJ | USA | OF |
| Full Armor Falcons Elite | 28 | Jake Schilling | 2021 | Pennsbury | Levittown | PA | USA | C |
| Cage Academy | 34 | Brandon Schmitt | 2021 | Woodbridge (Woodbridge, NJ) | Woodbridge | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 6 | Matthew Seibert | 2022 | Warwick | Lititz | PA | USA | LHP |
| Pascack Valley | 5 | Collin Shevlin | 2021 | High Tech (North Bergen, NJ) | Weehawken | NJ | USA | SS |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 13 | Nicholas Skokowski | 2021 | Cedar Cliff | Mechanicsburg | PA | USA | RHP |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 23 | Alex Smith | 2021 | Scotch Plains Fanwood | Scotch Plains | NJ | USA | RHP |
| PA Playmakers | 33 | Chase Smith | 2022 | | West Chester | PA | USA | SS |
| HV Bulldogs | 13 | Sean Smith | 2022 | Arlington | Poughquag | NY | USA | RHP |
| Pascack Valley | 42 | Anthony Sodano | 2023 | P27 Academy | Johns Island | SC | USA | LHP |
| North Atlantic Select | 5 | Joseph Spaccavento | 2022 | Northern Highlands Reg H | Upper Saddle River | NJ | USA | OF |
| Legends Prospects | 44 | Ashton St. Pierre | 2022 | Kingswood Regional | Tuftonboro | NH | USA | LHP |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 22 | Jake Stollar | 2022 | Hunterdon Central | Flemington | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Bronx Bombers | 22 | Christopher Suero | 2022 | All Hallows | Bronx | NY | USA | OF |
| PA Playmakers | 5 | Dan Sullivan | 2022 | St. Joseph's Prep | Drexel Hill | PA | USA | OF |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 33 | Hawkins Sutter | 2023 | The Lawrenceville School | Princeton | NJ | USA | SS |
| NY Prospects | 6 | Michael Todaro | 2022 | Lacey Twp | Forked River | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Pascack Valley | 32 | Zach Traina | 2021 | Pascack Valley | Hillsdale | NJ | USA | 3B |
| New Jersey Nationals | 32 | Steven Trone | 2022 | Riverside | Leesburg | VA | USA | RHP |
| NJ Axemen | 28 | Lukas Tsai | 2022 | Bergen Catholic | Fair Lawn | NJ | USA | C |
| RCBC Nationals | 22 | AJ Vigliotti | 2021 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | C |
| Legends Prospects | 12 | Eric Wing | 2021 | St. John's Preparatory | Georgetown | MA | USA | OF |
| Keystone Diamondbacks | 11 | Brandon Wingenroth | 2022 | Lancaster Catholic | Manheim | PA | USA | SS |
| Hunterdon Hurricanes | 10 | Jared (Jp) Witt | 2021 | Ridge (Basking Ridge, NJ) | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | 1B |
| NY Storm Albany | 10 | Craig Woolley | 2021 | Niskayuna | Niskayuna | NY | USA | OF |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 26 | Matty Wright | 2022 | Somerville | Branchburg | NJ | USA | OF |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 17 | Davin Wydner | 2022 | Merritt Island | Viera | FL | USA | 1B |
| NY Prospects | 18 | Timothy Yorks | 2022 | St. Joseph by the Sea | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Diamond Jacks Super 13s | 50 | Donovan Zsak | 2022 | St Joseph | Scotch Plains | NJ | USA | LHP |